BlueBay Brokers Investment Memo
Comparable sibling listing (#1914) ↗
THE CLUB AT BRICKELL BAY
Short-Term Rental Yield Analysis

THE CLUB AT BRICKELL BAY · Residence 2608

1200 Brickell Bay Dr # 2608, Miami FL 33131 · 1 Bed / 1 Bath · 818 sq ft · Built 2004
$450,000Other ViewShort-term allowedUnits managed by Property Management Brickell
City of Miami order, 11 August 2026

The city ordered The Club's association to stop stays under 30 days, saying the building lacks the certificate of use for transient lodging; the association contests the order. In late October 2026 the city issued a notice of violation for use not in compliance with the certificate of use and mailed a citation to the association's board, with a Code Enforcement Board hearing reported as tentatively set for 9 December 2026 (CBS Miami and The Real Deal, 23 October 2026). No ruling had been published when we checked on 14 November 2026. The income below is what units in the building earned; ask us for the status the week you make an offer.

Prepared for a BlueBay Brokers investorProfessionally-managed STR
Purchase price
$450,000
$550 / sq ft
HOA
$700/mo
full-service building
Property tax
$6,736/yr
~1.5% of price
Cap rate (base)
5.5%
unlevered, honest
THE CLUB AT BRICKELL BAYTHE CLUB AT BRICKELL BAYTHE CLUB AT BRICKELL BAYTHE CLUB AT BRICKELL BAY

Tenancy & possession

Not a vacant flip — a tenant is in place today, on a long-term lease from the current owner. The STR numbers below start once that lease ends.

Current tenant, in place$3,025/mo
Lease runs toNovember 2026
FurnitureTenant's — not included
Fastest possession of the four — Steve's pick

Of the four off-market Club 1/1s shown together by the listing agent (#1914, #2608, #2304, #3018), this is the earliest possession outside of #2304's 60-day clause — about three months ahead of #3018 and five ahead of #1914. It also carries the highest in-place rent of the four. Budget for holding it as a rental through November 2026, then furnishing it (~$20,000) before converting to STR.

This unit is off-market — no MLS listing exists. Pricing and building facts (HOA, tax) are modeled against the identical 818 sq ft floorplan currently listed as #1914 (MLS A12006455) one stack over; #2608's own price ($450,000) and unit number are confirmed directly by the listing agent, not by MLS. Listing agent Liana Doganiero (The Keyes Company) is offering a 3% co-broke commission. Source: WhatsApp thread with the listing agent, 16–18 Jul 2026 — verify directly before writing an offer.

The revenue basis

STR revenue here is a real 1BR we manage in this building, not a generic estimate.

Managed 1BR in the same building — as reportedTrailing 12 mo
Occupancy (owner-blocked summers)73%
Average daily rate$192
Gross revenue as reported$52,100
Restored to a full-time investor rental

that owner self-occupied every summer — May–August ran 45–54% while the building's other managed units held 80–90%. Removing the summer blocks restores the unit to ~83% occupancy. At ~83% blended that is $58,500 gross — the base case. Cross-check: the strongest occupancy in our managed pool in this building ran 86%, on a larger floorplan.

Annual pro-forma — base case

Professionally-managed short-term rental. Base revenue $58,500.

Gross STR revenue$58,500
Professional STR management (20%)−$11,700
HOA ($700 × 12)−$8,400
Property tax−$6,736
Insurance (condo, STR)−$2,000
Utilities + internet−$2,640
Supplies, turnover, reserves (~4%)−$2,340
Net operating income (NOI)$24,684

Unlevered cap rate = $24,684 ÷ $450,000 = 5.5%.

Cash vs financed

The same $24,684 NOI, two ways to own it.

All cash

Cash in (price + ~3% closing)$463,500
Net operating income+$24,684
Cash yield≈ 5.3%

25% down, financed

Cash in (down + closing)$126,000
NOI − debt ($337,500 @ 7.25%)−$2,944/yr
+ principal paydown yr 1+$3,159
Monthly cash flow≈ −$245/mo

Three revenue scenarios

Same $450,000. Only the STR revenue assumption changes (cap = NOI ÷ price).

Conservative
$52,100
cap 4.4%
★ Base
$58,500
cap 5.5%
Optimistic
$60,200
cap 5.8%
GrossNOI Conservative$52k Base$58k Optimistic$60k Gross STR revenue Net operating income

Next step

Model your exact numbers

I'll walk you through STR set-up, financing options, and run the live numbers for this unit.

Regulatory disclosure — short-term rental legality at this building

A Miami Herald investigation (July 16, 2026) and Editorial Board opinion (July 20, 2026) examined short-term rental compliance at The Club at Brickell Bay, reporting that roughly 545 of the building's 643 units operate as short-term rentals while only a small subset holds a valid city Certificate of Use for lodging. Florida law (Fla. Stat. §509.242) requires a building-wide Change of Occupancy once more than 25% of units convert to short-term use — a threshold this building has passed. A new HOA board took office in June 2026 and has stated it intends to pursue proper registration. The short-term rental revenue in this analysis reflects actual historical operating performance, not a guarantee of continued legality — buyers should independently confirm current compliance status before purchase.

Assumptions & disclosures

Revenue from a 1BR we manage in this building. Cap rates are honest, unlevered NOI ÷ price (4.4% / 5.5% / 5.8%). 25%-down case uses a $337,500 mortgage (75% LTV, 7.25%, 30-yr); rates vary by lender.
  • Florida short-term-rental taxes (~13%) — Miami-Dade tourist + state sales tax — are collected from the guest and remitted; not an owner expense above but filed on every stay.
  • The tax side: held as a short-term rental with stays of 7 days or less on average, a furnished unit can deduct a large part of its price in its first year. How the Miami STR tax strategy works.
  • No appreciation assumed in the yield figures. Not tax or lending advice — verify with your CPA and lender.